In a contemporary SEC submitting this morning, Twitter shared a letter it acquired from Elon Musk’s authorized workforce indicating displeasure with the corporate’s provided data relating to the extent of “spam and pretend accounts” on its service. This is identical concern that the expertise entrepreneur has posted about extensively since his deal to purchase the social media platform was settled earlier within the yr.
Per the letter — which you’ll be able to learn in its entirety here — Musk considers Twitter’s “newest provide to easily present further particulars relating to the corporate’s personal testing methodologies, whether or not via written supplies or verbal explanations, [as] tantamount to refusing [his] knowledge requests,” requests that the SpaceX and Tesla CEO says will assist “facilitate his analysis of spam and pretend accounts on the corporate’s platform.”
The letter says that extra knowledge (and never simply clarification of how the present knowledge was gathered) on Twitter’s non-human customers — each pure and spam — is necessary for serving to shut the transaction from a financing perspective. “As Twitter’s potential proprietor, Mr. Musk is clearly entitled to the requested knowledge to allow him to arrange for transitioning Twitter’s enterprise to his possession and to facilitate his transaction financing,” the letter reads.
On the finish of the brief correspondence, Musk’s authorized workforce threatens to kill the deal (emphasis: TechCrunch):
Based mostly on Twitter’s conduct to this point, and the corporate’s newest correspondence particularly, Mr. Musk believes the corporate is actively resisting and thwarting his data rights (and the corporate’s corresponding obligations) beneath the merger settlement. This can be a clear materials breach of Twitter’s obligations beneath the merger settlement and Mr. Musk reserves all rights ensuing therefrom, together with his proper to not consummate the transaction and his proper to terminate the merger settlement.
Combating phrases certainly.
Within the wake of Musk’s numerous strikes to at first influence the social network, and later to purchase it wholesale, the controversial poster has made a lot of claims about how Twitter counts non-human customers. Musk went so far as tweeting excrement-themed emojis at Twitter’s CEO on the social service, after Parag Agrawal penned a thread on how the corporate handles spam and bots.
The tempo at which Musk went from charging headfirst into forcing Twitter to simply accept his bid, valuing the corporate at $54.20 per share, to attacking the corporate, its management and knowledge regarding non-human customers, was speedy — and, many speculated, indicative of his want to not full the deal on the agreed upon worth. For the reason that deal was pressured into existence, the worth of expertise shares has broadly fallen, making the transaction seem costlier as time has gone alongside.
Now now we have, from Musk’s workforce, a transparent risk that he might stroll if he doesn’t get extra data. Whether or not Musk’s calls for are in good religion we depart to you. However the scenario does elevate an fascinating conundrum. If Twitter does need to power Musk to pay up on the agreed-upon worth, it might concede and share extra knowledge. But when it does, what’s to cease Musk from shitposting on Twitter concerning the disclosed data? His letter says that he’ll “after all adjust to the restrictions offered beneath Part 6.4, together with by guaranteeing that anybody reviewing the information is sure by a non-disclosure settlement,” however does anybody take that declare critically?
Fortunately, if Twitter doesn’t need to promote to Musk — recall that the corporate initially enacted a poison-pill defense to fend off his overtures — it might probably merely not share any extra data, permitting its potential acquirer to attempt to wriggle out of the deal.
Traders are betting that the latter case is extra seemingly, promoting shares of Twitter this morning, pushing the worth of the corporate’s inventory down by 5.6% because the markets prepped for the open.
Leave a Reply