An app developer’s lawsuit over App Retailer rejections, scams and fraud has led to a settlement settlement after courtroom filings present a request to dismiss the go well with earlier this summer time. The plaintiff, app developer and former Pinterest engineer Kosta Eleftheriou, made a reputation for himself in current months calling out a few of the most egregious App Retailer scams. This later culminated in a lawsuit of his own against Apple, filed in California’s Superior Courtroom in Santa Clara County in March 2021, the place he alleged his personal app had been unfairly rejected from the App Retailer after which later focused by scammers, resulting in misplaced revenues.
The case had been a high-profile instance of developer discontent with Apple’s App Retailer enterprise. Many builders have change into dissatisfied not solely with the requirement to pay Apple commissions on their very own gross sales — one thing Epic Games is suing over currently — but additionally the how the App Retailer mannequin itself incentivizes scammers to tear off and revenue from professional builders’ work. However few take these issues courtroom, as Eleftheriou had carried out.
His criticism alleged that not solely had Apple rejected his FlickType Apple Watch keyboard app from the App Retailer, it then authorised competitor keyboard apps and others that used an built-in model of FlickType keyboard to publish to the App Retailer. This seemingly contradicted Apple’s claim that the FlickType keyboard supplied a “poor person expertise,” on condition that Apple’s personal app evaluate workforce was greenlighting the identical know-how when built-in into different apps like Nano for Reddit, Chirp for Twitter, WatchChat for WhatsApp and Lens for Instagram.
As well as, when the keyboard app was allowed to reenter the App Retailer, its early success made it a goal for App Retailer scammers who launched much less usable opponents boosted by pretend rankings and evaluations.
In consequence, FlickType’s personal income dropped from $130,000 in its first month to only $20,000 as customers went for the “better-rated” alternate options, the developer stated.
Following the filing of the case last year, the 2 events participated in courtroom calls with a decide, the courtroom docket exhibits, together with as lately as this spring. A request for dismissal of the lawsuit was subsequently filed on July 21, 2022, after Apple and Kpaw (Eleftheriou’s enterprise) got here to an settlement.
Eleftheriou was unable to touch upon the phrases of the settlement. Apple was not instantly in a position to touch upon the dismissal both.
Nevertheless, it’s laborious to think about the developer would have agreed to dismiss the case if phrases weren’t not less than considerably agreeable, given his ongoing criticism of Apple’s App Retailer enterprise and the hardships builders face.
Final yr, for instance, Eleftheriou served because the supply for information tales about App Store scams like a crypto wallet app that scammed a person out of his life financial savings (~$600,000); a children recreation that contained a hidden online casino; and a VPN app that scammed its users out of $5 million per yr, amongst others. His findings have been additionally introduced up in a line of questioning throughout a Senate antitrust hearing in April 2021, when Apple Chief Compliance Officer Kyle Andeer as to why Apple was not in a position to find these kinds of scams itself, given they have been “trivially simple to establish,” citing Eleftheriou’s work.
Extra lately, the FTC highlighted pretend App Retailer evaluations as part of a bigger motion towards rental platform Roomster, in its lawsuit filed this week — a sign that if Apple wouldn’t take motion, it could.
Although App Retailer evaluations proceed to be a difficulty, Apple has made some concessions associated to builders’ wants within the time since Eleftheriou’s lawsuit was filed.
Final fall, Apple brought back the “Report a Problem” button on the App Store, which invitations the general public to assist it combat apps committing fraud. It additionally updated its App Store Guidelines in June of final yr to crack down on fraud and scams by promising to take away scammers from the Apple Developer Program.
However extra work nonetheless must be carried out, as app builders are nonetheless too usually left with no recourse however to put up to Twitter or attain out to the media to have their complaints heard when a scammer is impacting their enterprise and revenues. That was recently the case with Authenticator app developer Kevin Archer, who detailed in a Twitter thread how he continues to face subscription scammers on the App Retailer who copied his professional app, then beg for evaluations throughout onboarding and push a subscription on customers upon first launch.
Whereas settling smaller lawsuits like Eleftheriou’s could also be routine for a corporation of Apple’s measurement, the eye they obtain — not solely amongst builders but additionally within the broader neighborhood of Apple customers — just isn’t one thing Apple possible desires to handle at current. The corporate notably desires to keep away from destructive public perceptions of its enterprise at a time when the U.S. Justice Division is in the early stages of filing an antitrust lawsuit concentrating on Apple.
As for Eleftheriou, he hasn’t given up on app improvement, regardless of all these points.
The developer says he’s now engaged on a mission associated to an iPhone keyboard however doesn’t have additional particulars to share at the moment. Notably, his amended criticism referenced difficulties with constructing keyboard apps as Apple by no means made accessible a developer API to request “Full Entry” immediately from the keyboard. He additionally argued that Apple constrains third-party keyboards in areas like accessible reminiscence, the flexibility to assemble knowledge to make higher predictions, the flexibility for use in password fields and restrictions over displaying visible components above the keyboards, the criticism acknowledged.
Eleftheriou couldn’t say but what, if something, has since modified on this entrance and that his new app could possibly deal with.
He’s nonetheless looking out for scams, too. Utilizing a software tool he built to establish App Retailer subscription scams and fraud, Eleftheriou realizes there’s nonetheless rather more work that must be carried out.
“Simply the opposite day, I re-ran my scam-finding software and was capable of finding a number of new rip-off apps inside 5 minutes, and this clearly impacts customers and builders alike,” he famous.